The record was broken for us fans: The end of the NEW Four Seasons left the fans dismayed at what was happening. Communications were less speedy back then with no internet or cell phones and snail-mail between the UK and USA was as it is now [a week] but quarterly Newsletters kept fans informed of what was known, which was very little. Rumour and counter-rumour bounced around. John Paiva tried to keep the band together as an entity but the inability to trade on their name ( a contract limitation put in place by Attorney Peter Bennett) and the expense of marketing themselves (and touring) to their world wide fan base was something they didn't feel they could do. And they needed a recording deal.
Rex Woodard's take on the period reveals the rumours and uncertainty…
“The last concert of the tour had occurred at Radio City Music Hall on October 8. Warner-Curb wanted to tape the performance for an album but Private Stock, Valli's label, refused permission. The actual final appearance took place on November 22nd 1977 at the Aladdin in Las Vegas. Fans reacted with puzzlement when the group quit singing any songs from the 'Helicon' album late in the tour. That hardly seemed to make sense since any future Four Seasons stage act would require new material to perform. Serious questions also arose as to who would remain in the new group. Valli announced that Lee Shapiro would split off to be Valli's full-time arranger. Since Valli had told reporters on several occasions that “he wouldn't be surprised” if Gaudio rejoined the group on stage, at least in the beginning …..did this mean Gaudio would replace Shapiro? Gaudio denied this rumour. Reports also circulated that the Four Seasons management was talking to a couple of performers with styles similar to Valli's in order to duplicate the old songs on stage when the new group resumed touring. By early 1978 the true picture emerged. The Four Seasons no longer existed. Paiva reportedly 'retired' from the music business and Barry Manilow hired Polci away for several projects.”
In fact, in complete disillusionment, Gerry Polci was talking of leaving the business altogether but through contacts joined the Barry Manilow touring band. Frankie Valli had persuaded Lee Shapiro to stay on as his musical director and he asked him to hire a group of musicians and lead his 'solo' band as musical director. Lee found top quality 'jazz' musicians to form the band and a team of male and female session singers for the back-up vocals. The band included pianist Mitch Foremen, guitarist Tim Breen, Harvey Auger on bass, drummer Ron Tierne and Richard Garcia on percussion. Lee didn't have much choice, at least he had a job offer!
“I was given the choice to remain a "Season" or go out as Frankie's Musical Director. I chose the latter because I didn't have as much confidence in the success of a "new" non- Frankie- Four Seasons (without the name) as I did an "established" non-Four Seasons- Frankie Valli.”
John Paiva found recovery from the break-up very tough to take:-
“The group had broken up and I now needed a place to stay. My brother Bob who at that time was living in the Hollywood, area agreed to put me up for a while so I could look up some contacts in hopes of scaring up some work. I think put UP with me would be more accurate. He has always been a loner and my presence was more than a little disturbing, but he was totally cool. My brother truly became my brother in that period of time. Every once in a while he would slip me a hundred dollar bill. Nothing attached. Just a helping hand. I will never forget this. It wasn't the money, it was the circumstances. I needed him and he was there. His place was a stones throw from the Improv Comedy Club. While we were in Vegas the last time, a comedian who was a fan of the Seasons was also appearing. He was to MC the Johnny Carson show one night and was interested in signing the group for it. I was looking forward to that as I had been watching the Carson Show since it started and the Doc Severinson band was so hip, who wouldn't want to do that show. I was quite surprised when Gerry who knew I was in LA called and said the show was on and asked if I was interested. Don was on the east coast but Lee flew out to conduct and we did the show with Frankie and the girl backup singers who were also in LA. Sitting in that band was a real high. We did 'Swearing To God.' It is quite ironic that another party should hire the former Seasons to back Frankie Valli after such an experience…but it happened.”
The break-up experience haunted John for some years until he wrote down his feelings in his biography:-
“Since my experience with The Seasons I have had re-curing dreams. I am always late, in the wrong uniform, at the wrong venue or some other horror trip for a musician. I believe that the falling apart of what I thought of as a family, destroyed my ability to function in a total norm. For years I have tried to understand why I was so injured. Don also suffered, but Gerry and Lee seemed unscathed. In a meeting I had with Don in May of 1996 at his home in Jersey he finally gave me a way of understanding what took place. Lee was a super talent at a very tender age as was Gerry and both came into this hit group. I on the other hand had spent 15 years trying to get there only to have it explode in my face. Don had worked so hard and invested so much energy that he too was hurt by this. Yet he seemed not as devastated as I. Finally he gave me some perspective when he said: “John, for Lee and Gerry, The Seasons was merely a stepping stone in their careers. We on the other hand thought that we had made it! We had been working toward that goal. It was something that we both wanted.” Don hit it on the head that day. Since that conversation, my horror dreams have lessened. They are not completely gone but this perspective has been a help.............. Thanks DJ.”
JOHN PAIVA — THE FOUR SEASONS
But John today also remains grateful to former Seasons Gerry Polci:-
“I found out recently that I have a lot to thank Gerry for in getting me into the Four Seasons….not only for spotting me playing with the Happenings and recommending me to Bob, Frankie and the other guys…..but he was the one that argued for my inclusion in the group when Joe was let go. Frankie thought I was too fat for the new, young looking image he wanted for the group. Gerry argued that my musical contribution would more than compensate for any 'image' negativity that was being perceived. Fortunately for me he was convincing.” “And again I must reiterate. I think 'Helicon' was a great album, perhaps a bit ahead of its time. I, as a musician, never cared about the marketing value. The Seasons played and sung and arranged their butts off for this project and even if I stand alone, I love the project and I am proud to have been a part. The only resentment which still holds true today more than 30 years later, is the way we were treated as members of the Four Seasons. At no time was I made to feel a true member. The money was never what it should have been for a R&R star, and when the end came, the rug was pulled from under us and the door slammed shut. 'Helicon' should have been our beginning and for what ever reason, it was our end. A couple of years later, some of the guys toured again with Frankie, and I was not called. A little salt in the wound? perhaps. On the other hand, by then I was starting a new life in Germany and who knows what might have happened if I had been called? It hurt to not even have been given a chance, but being hurt or rejected is a major part of show biz.”
Rex Woodard again on more rumours that circulated in fan newsletters[the only way to share news back then]:-
“Gaudio and Valli never intended for the group to fade away. From their office in Beverly Hills (listed as the “Four Seasons Partnership”) they contemplated alternatives. Ciccone stated in April 1978 that he would remain in the Four Seasons with three new members. The new group would be Gaudio's vehicle to explore new musical horizons. This concept never got off the ground. A second rumour had Joe Long rejoining the group. Their attention became diverted with Valli's solo career. Valli left Private Stock in January and signed a one record deal to record “Grease” for RSO. ……. “Grease” was recorded in the style of the Four Seasons more than in Valli's preferred ballad mode”
Bob Gaudio supposedly remained keenly interested in new directions notwithstanding the collapse of the Four Seasons….after their 'rock' experiment. Lee Shapiro observed:-
“The most difficult thing to achieve in the music business is to gain the trust of investors (record co. or individual) to believe in your dream. Bob did that repeatedly.”
Ironically Bob's interest in FM Rock took him to a concert in San Fransisco – He saw 'Stoneground' in concert and he liked the group so much he wanted to produce their next album. 'Heart Of Stone' was released on Warner Curb BSK 3187 in 1978. With Judy Parker he wrote a song called 'Deeper Than Love' which appears on the album. [Listen to it here] The song was a perfect style for the NEW Four Seasons and would have been an ideal launch to their split from Valli. 'Stoneground' didn't release it as a single. The song re-surfaced in a harmony arrangement similar to the Seasons sound by the Temptations on their 'Close To You' album in 1984.
Frankie Valli spent the first half of 1978 doing live 'solo' concerts. The band was “blowing him away” and Lee had to tone down their playing. And his final release on Private Stock was the album 'Frankie Valli 'Hits'' PVLP1041 which came out in the USA in April 1978 on PS 7012 - "Special Limited Edition" containing only eight tracks. (My Eyes Adored You/Our Day Will Come/We're All Alone/ Boomerang/ Swearin' To God/Fallen Angel/Easily/Rainstorm). The company would go bust within six months.
The US fan club “papered over” the split saying the band couldn't have stayed together….it was complete 'bullshit' but even Steve Bailey couldn't explain it. He said of the split: ”Why? It is so hard to say”.
All he could do was offer some unconvincing observations as to why it happened. Only now do we know some of the truth but as for the reasons behind the decision…only Bob and Frankie [and their then Attorney – Peter Bennett] knew that. It was a decision that would effectively destroy the sound and identity of the group, but perhaps on the face of it, success as a solo artist for Frankie heralded a bright new future and that clearly was his priority.
Suddenly as Rex Woodard described, Frankie Valli was asked by Barry Gibb if he would like to do the title song the Bee Gees had written for the movie of the show 'Grease'. He felt Valli's voice would best capture the 60's feel he wanted from the song. He jumped at the chance recording it in a style reminiscent of his up-tempo 60s solo tracks ( c/f 'You're Ready Now')
'Grease' came out in the UK on 45 on August 17th 1978 and a week later it zoomed into the charts at #58 eventually reaching #3 (on 30th September for 2 weeks) and having been released in May in the USA it reached #1 there by August (also #1 in Australia and Holland). The movie score LP also achieved #1 in the LP charts. A Frankie Valli album was rushed out, by Bob Gaudio producing with the help of old friend Charles Calello and released by Warner Bros /Curb by 9th September in the USA 'Frankie Valli Is The Word' BKS 3233
Frankie strangely publicly issued a 'Frankie Valli Regrets!' article in Pop Biz in Holland saying he was returning to the 4 Seasons.
“After a short career as a solo singer he is returning to the group with whom he had hits all over the world.” He was quoted as saying… 'I regret the success I had with 'Grease' …..It is just like going to bed with someone else. At first it is very nice but afterwards you get a nasty knock'….”What I wanted for such a long time was a solo hit, but 'Grease' was an all too easy success. Anybody could have had a hit record with this song…..It is a fantastic song but my musical part in it is zero. I just feel like a juke-box played by someone else. That's why I am returning to the Four Seasons. It is with them I want to make new hits. After all we as the Four Seasons have had more hits than the Bee Gees.”
A simply crazy response to a world wide #1 record. It would be his last and well remembered HIT. To add to the confusion for fans a German magazine 'Musik Joker' quoted him as saying…”I am a solo singer and I want to stay a solo singer in the future” Maybe it really was a joke!
Rumours emerged that the 3 back-up singers (Krystal Davies, Jean Graham and Jim Zimmerman) had left the band and had sued Frankie and this rumour coincided with him canceling all of his October concert dates
'Frankie Valli Is The Word' BKS 3233, featuring the hit single 'Grease', was a colossal failure, reaching only #160 in the US album charts and probably led Frankie to realise that as a solo artist he couldn't survive. The fact is, that by 1978, the Four Seasons omnipresence in all of Valli's work made the idea of a successful solo career a weak concept. And The Four Seasons name….was ….just like the Beach Boys with theirs…. 'lashed forever more to the mast of their own back-catalogue'. He could never escape it and never has. Why he tried to, is difficult to say, but all we can do is speculate it was down to ego or bad advice?
George Ingram saw the last SOLO concert of 1978 before the winter break at Resorts International Hotel/Casino at Atlantic City on 17th November. George commented that “Frankie's voice seemed to falter in places and the non - Four Seasons back-up vocals were really not up to standard.” He clearly needed “to get back with the Four Seasons” was George's assessment. Fans generally found the shows disappointing both vocally and musically. Rumours surfaced that he would not re-commence shows until April 1979
Frankie tried to explain himself in an interview which was published in the UK 'emergency newsletter' from April 1979
"Even knowing how laid back he is doesn't prepare you for the casual way he drops the surprising news that he's been working to get back with the 4 Seasons to do a tour and record an album from it. "There's a possibility that we may do a re-union tour so that we can cut a live album with 'Frankie Valli and the 4 Seasons', he says. We never cut a live album and I was with them for 17 years. We've gotten an incredible amount to mail from people asking us to do it. So we are going to cut one" What is it going to take to put it together? "It would take a whole lot" he answers, "But whatever it would take it would be worthwhile. It would be a fun tour. We'd probably take something like 20 days which is plenty of time to cut an album" . He's aiming at this winter as the target date for the tour but he makes it clear that the re-union might not end with the tour. "The group kind of quit itself in the middle of its own success” he explains. (In fact he sacked them….ed) "It was just one of those situations. People were not accepting the group without me being in it and the group itself was not accepting it as much as it should have, because it could have been successful. Most people think of the 4 Seasons and immediately put me in it. For the 17 years I was with the group I was the only lead singer they had." Last year was the first he worked without them. "We've called a couple of them and they are very interested in doing this" he adds. Why would a performer, who had struck out on his own and had such success as Valli had with 'Grease and his Las Vegas career, want to re-group the people he left to find that success. "In my situation the 4 Seasons were such an intimate part of my life that my ego doesn't get in the way.....to say that I would never do that again" he says " I enjoyed doing that or I would never have done it to start with. "
What a distortion of reality this was to re-establish his success!!
This was his take on the end of the NEW 'Four Seasons' and what had been their growing self-identity. His reaction to solo 'block bookings' in places like Las Vegas ….he says, in the rest of the article …..was that he “couldn't work nightly in the same place with an orchestra backing him”, even though he aspired to match his hero Frank Sinatra. He couldn't give an explanation for why he wouldn't invest in the now 'former' group and their worldwide reputation from the 'Who Loves You' album and the world tour. Now he realised he needed a new band and a new direction. The big mistake finally came home to roost and he saw his popularity fading.
Lee Shapiro by this time was disillusioned. He had been a huge creative talent in the group, expanding his experience as arranger and producer working with the group and Valli solo. John Paiva recalled one example of Lee's work….
“Lee Shapiro was a brilliant talent as an arranger. When we were to go to Las Vegas to play, Frankie decided he wanted a string section of 25 guys to accompany us on the show. This decision was the night before we were to travel. So on the flight Lee wrote the whole arrangement up and had it duplicated when we arrived. The string section delivered a perfect rendition on the night of the concert and had no problem reading Lee's charts.”
But Lee felt he couldn't find that expressive role anymore. He needed to move on and be more creative. He became an inventor, but maybe as a performer and arranger he could still achieve something? He left his role with Frankie on 12th July 1979 ironically again at the Las Vegas Aladdin Hotel Showroom. Jim Henry, Frankie's road manager also left after this date, but he would return later. The shows were deteriorating and Frankie was struggling to get the right 'sound' from his changing entourage.
During this time Frankie phoned Gerry Polci and Don Ciccone and persuaded them to return. Money was an important factor in winning them over after the previous 'sacking' fiasco
As the year ended Bob Crewe was back after his road accident and working again with Frankie who had a Crewe/Brown penned new release. 'Fancy Dancer'( L.Russell Brown – Bob Crewe) b/w 'Needing You' (Valli-Tighe-Shapiro) Warner-Cub WBS 8734.RE1. The 'A' side produced by Bob Gaudio and L.Russell Brown and arranged by “Hall & Bones” was a somewhat lightweight disco number and became a minor hit (#77). Disco was surviving - for now.
But in the record business, a combination of factors where threatening all labels and artists. As Steve Knopper describes in 'Appetite For Self-Destruction – The Spectacular Crash Of The Record Industry In The Digital Age'.
“One man nearly destroyed the music industry in the late '70s. His name was Steve Dahl….and in a maniacally nasal voice, he pioneered shock radio with his outrageous stunts.”
He set out in 1979 to destroy the disco market. Knopper again….
“ Dahl's hatred for discos ran deep and personal. He took his radio “show on the road packing a suburban Chicago nightclub with a 'death to disco' rally….Why did rock fans in Chicago hate disco so much?....Because it 'sucked'. That's why. The songs, the dancing, the roller-skating, the disco balls, the heavy make-up- it was all so massive, so goofy and over the top.” “Disco sucks!...Disco sucks!....was the new mantra of white America….Almost thirty years later the idea of furiously hating disco seems ridiculous. It's incredible to me that rock fans would actually riot to hear REO Speedwagon and Foreigner on their local airwaves instead. Anyway disco's grooves never died they just went underground, in the form of 'house' music and other big-city warehouse happenings of the early 80s. But in 1979, discos had been rammed headlong into the wall of the brickhouse. “People were trying to murder it” says Gloria Gaynor.”
In 1979 there were 15 disco No 1's on the US chart out of 26 chart toppers. In 1980 there were 3 out of 16. Surprising in retrospect, and certainly something most Four Seasons fans were not aware of….and something not anticipated by Frankie and Bob Gaudio as in 1979. Bob Crewe was trying to revive Frankie's fortunes and a new album was being recorded. But Bob Crewe was reportedly unhappy with the result and re-recorded it …..“with Valli spending up to 14 hours in the studio at one time”….according to George Ingram. The LP was we were told was finished and a new single 'Passion For Paris' was lined up for single release. The US Newsletter advised that a whole album of disco numbers was recorded for release in the fall of 1979 but it was decided not to release the album and five disco tracks were selected to go with a series of ballads. The release date slipped further back.
In fact the original album tracks were recorded at Warner Bros Studio during the Spring and Summer of 1979 but agreement fell through and the ‘team’ turned to MCA for a record. The session tapes were done and only needed final mixing.
Subsequent Studio sessions followed for an album with MCA.
The Warner session tapes were all discovered during the Snapper Music Tape Research and resulted in a salvage of ‘The Lost Disco Album’ for inclusion in the Box Set. They were so good.
The salvaged tape contained unique alternative mixes and the ‘Unreleased’ track ‘Back In Action’ which can be heard by clicking the above image. This was another major find in the Snapper Music Box Set [2023].
Gaudio and Valli were also in 1979 found working with the Alessi Bros on their LP 'Words and Music' with the title track and 2 others produced by Bob Gaudio - 'Midnight Low' and 'Evil Man' with Frankie Valli doing back-up vocals on this disco targeted 5 minute 18 second track. No chart entry resulted though. This collaboration was in return for the 2 songs the brothers had contributed to the 'Valli' album back in 1976. ('Easily' and 'So She Says')
The US fan club was reported in October 1979 to be in financial difficulty too and no newsletters were coming out. Inflation and spiralling printing costs which combined with postage costs and production time for the newsletter meant people didn't get to know what was going on. (unlike today with the www…these were very different times) Membership obviously dropped dramatically. A US fan club Vice-President Steve Bailey resigned due to “non-co-operation difficulties” and communication from the Partnership was sporadic.
Even with the record industry in some distress as a result of a deflating disco market 'Passion For Paris' MCA 572 finally came out on 11th April 1980. Bob Crewe and soon to be new Four Season Jerry Corbetta wrote the song as a medley with 'An American in Paris' and it was targeted at the disco market.
But musically times were about to change and by 1981 the chart would be dominated by FM Rock and power ballads as Steve Knopper describes:-
“The reason disco died was economic, but it wasn't really a decision. As always, record labels went were the sales were, and for much of the late 70s that was disco….When disco fans stopped buying, record stores around the US suddenly found themselves inundated with millions of unwanted LP's. The stores had to return them to the labels. It was a recipe for music business disaster, and in 1979, labels started to crash. Sales plummeted that year by almost 11% after more than a decade of growth….Casablanca Records imploded…and almost killed PolyGram Records…CBS's flamboyant attack-dog Chairman Walter Yetnikoff, declared the industry “in the intensive care ward”
1979 had not been a good year for the music industry. Charlie Calello told us:-
”Basically, around 1979, the industry found out what the record companies were doing…back then the way the 'record companies' could work was the they could ship records out and once they shipped them to a store, they could log them as records sold and what they would do is wait for the returns...so what would happen is that if they wanted to get a record high on the charts is that they would press a million /two million records and send them out, so accounting for record sales, when maybe they would only sell 200,000 and they'd have to take 1.8m back: but what they did was hike the record to make the profit centres look good on their balance sheets and they did this for many years, abusing the privilege with the retailers until the RIAA made a switch, when they realized that some of these records really weren't selling and they couldn't chart records to be Gold or Platinum until they really had sales….and the record companies started getting bombarded with returns,,,and this was the brilliant move on the part of the 'racketeers' who started to bootleg records and put them in boxes and ship them back to the record companies and they would have to pay them returns without ever opening the cartons. When the record companies started to know what was going on it was already too late and they got scammed out of millions of dollars. And then what happened when they started to sell them off as 'cut-outs' they found out that many of the records were bootlegs and not the real masters and sometimes they were not even the records on the labels. It was a fiasco and the Corporations finally shut the record companies down and stopped that sort of accounting”.
Such accounting abuses can only go on for so long and by 1979 the 'scam' was exposed. Coupled with this exposure Billboard reported record companies were feeling the decline with sales at an all time low. Private Stock had gone bankrupt and getting a new deal with Warner-Curb seemed at risk for The Partnership when one exec said…”we are cutting back on borderline releases”.
A determined effort was being put into re-marketing the group and re-establishing the sales achieved in 1976 and 1977. We didn't know it at the time but Valli and his partly 're-united' Four Seasons had little chance of success. They were fortunate however that Warner-Curb were commissioning a 'Re-United 'Live' 'album. The lost opportunity to build on the success and world wide reputation of the group after the 'Who Loves You' album was perhaps being realised and a clear attempt to resurrect the groups popularity was apparent. Re-connecting with the public was clearly the aim, and the fans were desperate for something from ‘whoever’ would re-create a Four Seasons as they had fallen in love with.. Frankie Valli was determined to put every effort into re-establishing himself and the 'new' group with the public but as 'Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons' . With the prospect of a 'live' album, Frankie needed an experienced keyboard player and arranger/conductor. A new Four Season, Jerry Corbetta came in as preparations for the 'live' double album where underway. Jerry had performed with the group 'Sugarloaf' a Denver, Colorado based rock and roll band that performed from 1973 to 1975. Jerry had met Bob Crewe in 1975 when he was the band leader of the The Jam Band on the Disco-Tex and The Sex-O-Lets first album.
After a delay over 'contractual problems' the NEW 'new' Four Seasons..(sic!) assembled for rehearsal for a major tour . After performances at Valley Forge on 2-4th May the Four Seasons flew into the UK for 13 concerts to promote the VERY BEST OF FRANKIE VALLI album (MCA3198), the 'Passion For Paris' single. The aim was to re-capture the 'sound' of the old group that had toured in 1976 and 77 and re-establish the group's identity as well as Valli's 'SOLO' image.
The Jeffrey Kruger Organization who commissioned the tour said that the Valli tour grossed $260,000 with ticket prices around $10 at fifteen (actually 13 due to cancellations) 2, 000 seat concert halls. The management of the tour was probably the best ever and the access to the group for fans was appreciated by all who met and chatted with them.
Key additions to personnel which would help tie the new show format together for the forthcoming decade was the inclusion of Richard Garcia – long-standing friend of Valli and top percussionist. Guitarist Larry Lingle and notably Robbie Robinson joined the band, and is still Frankie's musical director today…48 years on (the longest ever Four Season, apart from Bob and Frankie). Using synthesizers he was able to replace the usual string quartet we had seen in previous tours. The very talented Toby Tyler provided a strong female voice to the harmony sound and to Valli's duets.
[Robbie Robinson has since clarified the record: he joined the band in August 1978, when Frankie was touring as FRANKIE VALLI without the Four Seasons. He took one year off touring in 1999, but remained active in recording and production behind the scenes and went out to conduct a show with the Hershey Symphony. In his words, “in reality I have been a part of the organization since 1978.”...ed]
11th May Brighton Center Brighton; 13th Royal Albert Hall London; 16th Apollo Theatre Manchester; 17th Odeon Birmingham; 18th The Hippodrome Bristol; 20th DeMontford Hall Leicester; 21st City Hall, Hull; 23rd Apollo Theatre Glasgow; 24th Usher Hall Edinburgh; 25th Capitol Theatre Aberdeen; 26th New Theatre Southport; 29th Guild Hall Portsmouth; 1st June New Theatre Oxford.